
Several years ago, I discovered something that was never taught in Teacher Training. This is the possible twinning problem in your classroom? We all of course, learn a lot about the tragedy of child abuse and the signs to watch out for in such cases. Nevertheless, we were never informed of all instances in which childhood behaviour can often mimic child abuse, and that you can be seriously caught out and embarrassed.
Fortunately, on this occasion I asked some questions first before reporting anything formally. It was then I discovered the unique phenomenon which I came to know as the “twinning problem”. I found a rare few knew of the problem, because it is not common.
Background to the Twinning Problem
This story begins with being called down to do some urgent supply work in a Home Economics class. This was not my forte at all, but the Vice Principal was confident in my troubleshooting abilities, or perhaps there was just no-one else available.
In any case, I found myself taking a “sewing class” for two 45-minute lessons. I had some work already set, but it was not quite enough for that full length of time. Before the students scurried around, I asked if they had learnt to hand sew buttons.
The vast majority in this all-female class had yet to learn how to hand sew a button. All were fairly competent with machinery sewing though. I breathed a big sigh of relief, for this was the one piece of sewing I actually knew. My mother made sure I was capable of sewing my own shirt and trouser buttons, and doing basic patchwork on clothes.
Twinning Problem Surfaces
Whilst I supervised the class, I noticed one small girl by herself, sitting dead still and staring into the distance. She didn’t make a move. The withdrawn, dazed look on her face gave me the chills. The other girls simply ignored her. I tried communicating, but she made no answer nor eye contact, though I knew she was listening, having saw her tense her body, just ever so slightly. Sensing anger was pointless and would do far more damage, I thought I saw a very clear case of possible child abuse. All the signs were present. Deciding to be proactive, I found a jar of coloured buttons and cloth from the back room to sew some practice buttons.
Still getting no eye contact or verbal answer to my questions, I put the coloured jar in front of her and gently asked if she would choose her own coloured buttons to sew, and I would show her how to sew them on. To my utter relief a small hand reached out and picked a button from the jar. She still did not look at me, or respond, maintaining her staring ahead, with head slightly inclined down to avoid eye contact.
I proceeded to demonstrate sewing a button in front of her eyes, and the young girl picked up a needle and followed my instructions and proceeded with her own work. She managed to complete the work pretty well, though it was clearly her first attempt.
Success and Satisfaction
At the end, a very worthy piece of sewing cloth with buttons was produced. Then something wonderful happened, she looked up at me for a brief moment, and gave the most beautiful genuine smile I had ever seen. My heart almost melted. Breakthrough! They tell you in teaching there are small moments which make the vocation worthwhile and leave you on “cloud nine” for a few weeks, which eases all the pain you receive. This was one such moment. That small smile healed a lot of teaching wounds.
Completing the rest of the lesson was somewhat of a triumph with successful buttons finished all around. Years later, I can still remember one student coming up and remarking: “Sir, remember how you taught me to sew my first button?”
So how does this relate to “twinning”. Well, I went to immediately check that child’s background, worried about abuse. After discussions, I found she had a twin sister. Apparently, they both talked like chatterboxes together, but displayed the same behaviour when apart. They had not been socialised properly outside their twin sister relationship. This was the “twinning problem”. A relation of mine who was a Vice Principal at another school, pinpointed it straight away, when I queried this behaviour.
Oh, that’s the “twinning thing”. She knew it instantly from long experience.
Just Remember Twinning!
So, if you ever come across a possible case of possible child abuse, matching all the signs, first check whether the child has a “twin”. It may save you a lot of embarrassment! It is a problem which may be encountered even within high schools.

